Friday, July 28, 2023

Glen Onoko: An Abandoned Opportunity

I used to live in North Carolina, a state similar to Pennsylvania in some ways. It’s politically a purple state with a conservative legislature that often elects democrats to statewide office. North Carolina has its problems, but it has always done two things exceedingly well: invest in its public university system, and fund its state parks and forests.

I was thinking about this last year while hiking near Glen Onoko falls, on state game lands near Lehigh Gorge State Park. I say “near” because, of course, the trail to the falls has been closed for several years due to a number of injuries and fatal falls. Despite the closing, the trail still draws visitors, and will continue to due to its scenic beauty and proximity to large population centers. Because this is one of the most popular and visited trails in the state, putting up barriers will not eliminate demand. People will continue to hike—and get hurt or even killed—along what has for many years been a poorly maintained pathway.

There are plenty of precarious spots that manage to safety cater to the public’s desire to hike in areas of great beauty. I can think of a number in neighboring states, such as Buttermilk Falls State Park in New York. Or consider North Carolina, which benefits hugely from tourism built around its well-maintained parks and forests. People travel from all over the country to hike the peaks, gorges and waterfalls of the Great Smokies and Black Mountains.

Pennsylvania may not have towering peaks like Grandfather Mountain or Mount Mitchell, but we have something NC doesn’t—close proximity to some of the largest metro areas in the country. Imagine the economic benefit the right sort of investment in our natural resources could bring for the millions of day trippers and weekend warriors if there was adequate visitor facilities, parking and infrastructure investment at all of our best-known trails.

Imagine Glen Onoko as a marquee attraction, luring people to stay and shop in this region of the Poconos. Imagine the conservation and water quality benefits of well-thought-out trail design and oversight in a sensitive natural area. From an ethical standpoint, imagine a state that does not fail to create a safe and accessible means for people to visit a regionally famous scenic area, rather than just putting up caution tape and looking the other way.

I urge Pennsylvania to make the investments needed to maximize the value of our public lands, both for our own residents and those who would love to enjoy our state as a safe and scenic getaway. 

 

Note: This was written in 2022 and sent to the Pennsylvania Parks and Forests Foundation, as well as state senators and legislators, including Bob Casey and Pat Toomey. Casey replied with boilerplate email "regarding federal lands" (not the subject of this piece) that clearly was plucked from a group of pre-written responses organized by rough category. Same for Toomey, who referenced the 2021 Protecting America's Wilderness and Public Lands Act, which concerns federal lands, wilderness designations and land acquisition, none in Pennsylvania.

Wednesday, March 10, 2021

How Did Biden Win Pennsylvania? The Suburbs

 
It’s not getting a lot of play in the national conversation post election, but the suburbs were massively important to the Biden victory in Pennsylvania.

The Democrats’ share of the total votes cast in Philly actually decreased vs 2016, but this difference was more than made up for by the increase in blue votes in just one suburban town—Lower Merion.

All over the collar counties, turnout rose as towns shifted left. Biden widened the margin in towns Clinton won and flipped or made big inroads in affluent, predominantly white towns that Trump won in 2016.

In the end, these counties—Chester, Delaware, Montgomery and Bucks—gave Biden a 293,000-vote margin over Trump in a state that Biden won by less than 81,000 votes.

It’s heartening to see how poorly Trump’s overtly racist appeals played in these counties. Biden will “destroy the suburbs” Trump said repeatedly, meaning open up affordable housing to those lower on the income scale.

There’s a lot of political dissension in the hinterlands and plenty of voters who may swing back red in future presidential contests, but at least the most nakedly demagogic appeal fell flat among its exact target audience.

It may even do fair housing advocates a favor, as his politicizing of zoning and housing issues forces the issue into people’s consciousness. Hypocrisy around affordable housing will be a tougher position to maintain; we are already seeing the effect of this in shifting attitudes in California, and local NIMBYS in my neck of the woods seem chastened, at least for the time being.

Wednesday, December 23, 2020

Hey, Joe—Some Thoughts to Make the Country Grow

Not as fun as Bob Dylan's advice for John Kennedy in 1963, but I do have some suggestions for Biden’s first term. Down-ballot difficulties demonstrate the importance of proactively demonstrating that centrist liberalism is America’s core, mainstream, functional politics, with the best chance to really move the nation forward.

  • Do something meaningful on the southern border. Show everyone there’s an alternative to Trumpism. Beef up drug interdiction at legal border crossings and put money back into the infrastructure for processing asylum seekers. Demonstrate how to treat all humans with basic dignity.
  • Make the promotion of democratic institutions, civil order and rule of law in Central America a foreign policy priority. Make clear the connections between instability in these countries and the flow of desperate people to our southern border. (Throw in a reminder of Trump’s cutting aid to those countries.)
  • Pursue police reform and frame this as an effort that will benefit both police and victims. Work to set up a robust mental health aid structure spearheaded by the training of unarmed first responders who specialize in dealing with crisis situations.
  • Infrastructure—yes! Do what Trump couldn’t deliver and invest in roads, rail, ports, wind, solar. This means having the balls to support pipeline projects, too—oil shipped in dangerous tanker trains & trucks is bad news. Show you are serious about realistic, phased energy transition.
  • Let’s strengthen the ACA with a public option, expanded medicaid. Hammer home how Republicans try to take away basic protections (incl. preexisting conditions) in the middle of a pandemic.
  • Aggressively address the plague of urban gun violence without threatening authoritarian measures. Strong federal support and targeted interdiction to staunch the cycle of gang retaliation. As Harvard’s Thomas Abt says, “to reduce violence, focus on the damn violence.”

Friday, October 23, 2020

Notes on Abortion and the Right to Privacy

The Amy Coney Barrett hearings were a lesson in the connection between the legal arguments for decriminalizing abortion and, earlier, contraception. If couples are free to choose whether or not to use contraception, based on religious or other convictions, the same could be true for abortion.

This seems like a sound legal argument and even, in a parallel legal universe, bears application of the Establishment Clause. One religious sect's view of contraception or abortion should not dictate everyone else's ability to access these things; our laws are not written to satisfy one set of beliefs over another (i.e. we do not outlaw pork or blood transfusions to satisfy Muslims or Jehovah's Witnesses).  

The Supreme Court chose instead to legalize contraception (in Griswold v. Connecticut, 1965) and abortion (Roe v Wade, 1972) based on the right to privacy, which stems from an interpretation of the due process clause of the 14th amendment: "No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States".

Privacy, being a privilege already recognized elsewhere in the Constitution and in common law, is interpreted as encompassing whether a couple decides to prevent pregnancy, or what a woman does early in a pregnancy. “In Roe, the court ruled that the state's compelling interest in preventing abortion and protecting the life of the mother outweighs a mother's personal autonomy only after viability. Before viability, the mother's right to privacy limits state interference due to the lack of a compelling state interest," explains Live Science.

Whatever one thinks of this particular application of the 14th Amendment, this interpretation of privacy seems to jive with longstanding historical precedent. In many traditional cultures, the fate of a pregnancy before the "quickening" (the movement of a fetus in the womb) is seen as more or less the business of the woman herself and her trusted confidants (usually other women such as female relatives or a local healer).1

Seen more broadly, the enshrining of a privacy doctrine in sexual and reproductive matters fits in well with an analysis of Western cultural history where, as the power of brute-force coercion diminished beginning in the 18th century, the state’s "right to observe" and insert itself into questions of sexuality through the lens of science, categorization and regulation increased. 2 Legal protections are therefore necessary to counter these modern forces that have led to specific repression and prosecution of sexual and reproductive "crimes" that in past eras were largely ignored by the state (including contraception, abortion and non-normative sexual practices such as homosexuality or S&M). 3

It is the “creep” of right-to-privacy arguments that animates some of the modern opposition to the liberalization of laws regarding sexuality and reproduction. After all, in past eras, infanticide was also largely overlooked, as was child sexual abuse. Are we to protect these activities under a privacy rubric? The difference is that while these activities were once tolerated (or even actively embraced) in some cultures, this is certainly not the case today. While there is no religious, moral, ethical or scientific consensus on abortion, there is universal consensus on infanticide. Rode v Wade covers this argument by recognizing that there does eventually come a point where the state has a compelling interest in preserving the life of a fetus, except in cases where a pregnancy becomes too dangerous for the mother or there are other strong medical reasons to intervene. 

1 In the novel A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, a faithful account of life for poor Irish in pre-WWI New York, a midwife learns a young mother with a three-month old baby is pregnant again. She produces a bottle of “evil-looking dark brown stuff” and tells the mother,” a good dose of this night and morning for three days and you’ll come around again.” Even though she is no longer able to nurse her baby, the mother refuses, saying she cannot kill anything. “It wouldn’t be killing,” the midwife replies. “It don’t count until you’ve felt life.” When the mother still refuses, the midwife leaves with some final advice: “If you keep running up and down the stairs, maybe you’ll have a miscarriage.”

2 These areas are associated with French philosopher Michel Foucault in his books Discipline and Punish and The History of Sexuality.

3 Obstetrics and pediatric medicine are obviously a blessing for woman and children, but with modern technology always comes the threat of using technological tools for governmental overreach. With laws in some states compelling multiple doctor visits, notification of a pregnant teenager’s parents, unnecessary ultrasounds, description of a fetal image by a doctor, the viewing of an ultrasound image or the broadcast of the sound of a fetal heartbeat, it’s no wonder “keep your laws off my body” has become a rallying cry.


Tuesday, November 6, 2018

OK, Let's Review

On Election Day 2018, let’s review where we stand with our compatriots on the Right.

The Republican Party of November 2018:


Does not talk much about tax cuts, health care and the deficit—their thee biggest talking points during the Obama era—because their approaches have proven ineffective, unworkable and/or unpopular.

Demonizes immigrants as dangerous “invaders,” then refuses to take responsibility when an anti-semite murders Jews, inspired by this premise.

Does not condemn a GOP candidate in California for saying a Christian part-Arab running for office is attempting to “infiltrate” Congress.

Whips up anti-semitic hate aimed at a Jewish anti-Communist freedom fighter and Ronald Reagan admirer, who has worked tirelessly to fight corruption and support civil society around the world (that would be George Soros)…
 
 … while at the same time accepting PAC money from illiberal dictators like Viktor Orban and going soft on Vladimir Putin, Bashar al-Assad and Mohammed bin Salman.

Actively works to undermine good government by leaving hundreds of jobs unfilled and elevating incompetent partisan hacks (such as Scott Pruitt and Ryan Zinke) to key posts.

Ignores science and a mounting climate crisis (reserving words like “crisis” to describe migrating bands of poor people), refusing to consider even bipartisan, market-based mitigation strategies like carbon pricing.

Actively undermines an investigation into Russian interference in American elections that has already produced enough credible evidence to ring up 32 indictments and guilty pleas—that’s 32 more than Whitewater, Benghazi, the Valerie Plame affair, the Torture Memos, the Bush White House “Lawyergate” mass email destruction and Hillary email controversies combined.

Has given up on addressing, much less prioritizing, a workable plan of resolution and exit strategy for the now 17-year war in Afghanistan, which has claimed the lives of over 2,370 U.S. military.

Has failed utterly to follow through on highly-touted infrastructure improvements necessary to maintain America’s economic competitiveness.

Passed a tax law designed to benefit the rich, with minimal tax benefits for the middle class (most of which sunset after a few years), which has exploded the deficit while generating little to no real wage growth—all while slashing IRS funds for rooting out tax fraud and corruption.

Controls a Congress that sits idly by as the executive branch attacks the free press, independent judiciary, electoral process and separation of powers, offering only a halfhearted defense of the right of legislators to defend the letter of the Constitution, while establishing new, damaging precedents for conduct in judicial appointments and supreme court nominations (remember Merrick Garland).

Refuses to take seriously ample evidence of vote suppression around the nation, some patently racially motivated, while touting unsubstantiated claims of widespread voter fraud. 

Thursday, March 15, 2018

From Creationism to Trump: How to Explain the Frustrating Forty Percent?

Back in the early years of the Iraq war, I remember being struck by two polls. One found that around 40 percent of Americans believed that Saddam Hussein was somehow involved in 9/11. The other asked how many American believe the world was created in the last 6000 years—again, around 40 percent.

In a Washington Post piece on Tuesday, I encountered this not-so-magic number once again. This time, it was the percentage of Americans who approve of the job Donald J. Trump is doing.

What is the deal here? Why are such frustrating ideas shared by this large, stable slice of the populace?

It’s interesting that each of these positions seem to have been arrived at very differently. The Hussein opinion from crass manipulation and insinuation out of the mouths of George W. Bush and others in his administration, exploiting post-9/11 fear and patriotism to drum up support for the Iraq War. New Earth Creationism from long-standing fundamentalist tradition. And the belief in Trump from… what?

It’s easy to just say ignorance. After all, some of the people interviewed for the Post article have some pretty ignorant things to say about Barack Obama’s nuclear weapons treaty with Iran.

But one thing these voters are not ignorant about is their own hometowns.

“Everybody is in a holding pattern. We’re waiting for the factories to return, but I know they will,” says a Trump fan who grew up in East Liverpool, Ohio. “… For the first time in many, many years, I’m optimistic.”

They’re not wrong about the hollowing out of Middle America, exploding income equality and the ever-increasing concentration of wealth in just a few regions. They’re not wrong about the disruptive nature of globalization, which has brought plenty of good and bad to the country—just none of the good, it seems, to East Liverpool. They’re not wrong to mistrust Wall Street, or to yearn for something radically different than the status quo that has upended their world in the last half century.

And they aren’t bamboozled by GOP tax cuts. Yesterday, Democrat Conor Lamb defeated Republican Rick Saccone in a Western Pennsylvania district that went for Trump by a 20-point margin last November. Much of the selling point for Saccone revolved around the recently enacted tax cuts.

But the Tump supporters in this district don’t love laissez-faire Capitalism the way New York bankers do, and they don’t necessarily believe in Paul Ryan-esque small government. They know that most of the tax cuts benefit the rich. They would probably gladly trade them for a TVA-style investment in Greene County, if it meant lots of jobs.  

These are long-standing truths of American populism that neither party does a good job of tapping into anymore. Trump gives it more lip service than anyone else, and they love him for it. Yet his presidency so far has shown an unwillingness or inability to follow through on his economic populism in any meaningful sense. This could be a huge opportunity for bold liberals, if the terms and outcomes were framed correctly.

Monday, January 29, 2018

King of Prussia Rail Map: Here's What the Line Looks Like

SEPTA has announced a finalized route for the proposed Norristown High Speed Line extension to King of Prussia. Planners chose a route taking advantage of PECO (electric/gas utility) and Pennsylvania Turnpike right of ways, avoiding any close contact with residential areas, before skirting the King of Prussia Mall on the way to a terminus next to the Valley Forge Casino.

Nowhere in any of the news reports (or on SEPTA's website promoting the project) can one find a decent map illustrating the route, so I created one.

King of Prussia Rail: Click Map to Enlarge

In order to mitigate local opposition, the route relies heavily on the Turnpike right of way, which surely helps drive up the cost (estimated at 1.2 billion). At this price, the pros and cons of such a project need to be carefully reckoned.

King of Prussia Rail: Pros


As SEPTA points out, the line would link the region's three major economic hubs: Center City, University City and King of Prussia (not to mention the Main Line). It would alleviate traffic and pollution in one of the most congested road corridors in the Northeast and be an economic boon for the area, cutting travel times and enabling a one-seat ride for shoppers, employees and residents. In addition to the mall and casino complexes, the line would provide access to the Chester Valley Trail, one of the most important of the Philadelphia Circuit Trails

King of Prussia Rail: Cons


The price, obviously. As pointed out by a community group, the station locations do not easily benefit  local residents as none outside the immediate mall area are pedestrian-friendly. Construction on and along the Turnpike will be an extended headache while the line gets built, and the line may encourage even more intense development along the edge of Valley Forge National Historic Park. (While coming tantalizingly close, the line does not facilitate pedestrian/bike access to the park due to Gulph Road and Route 422.)

Another factor to consider is that elements of the existing Norristown High Speed Line could prove the weakest links in a very expensive chain. It was just four years ago SEPTA was doing emergency repairs on the century-old Bridgeport Viaduct to replace rotting timbers. As SEPTA notes, an extensive rehabilitation project is still needed on the bridge—just the most high-profile of a number of issues resulting from decades of deferred maintenance on the underfunded rail line.

For King of Prussia Rail to succeed, SEPTA as a whole must be healthy. Perhaps SEPTA hopes KOP rail would make the NHSL (and the system as a whole) too big to fail.

Friday, January 19, 2018

On Both Sides of the Abortion Debate, the Key Question is One of Rights

As the pro-life movement has evolved, it has undergone a paradigm shift from a morals-based argument against abortion to a rights-based one, arguing for protections for the unborn in language pioneered by progressives in the Civil Rights and anti-war eras and carried forward through organizations such as Amnesty International and the ACLU.

This is roughly the point made in a fascinating New York Times piece, How the Pro-Life movement Has Promoted Liberal Values.

Left unmentioned is the thorny question—for pro-life and pro-choice advocates alike—of when, exactly, the unborn acquire rights. This question has always been on the table and is indeed baked into the fabric or Roe v Wade, which established a sliding-scale rule for when the state’s interest in protecting a fetus trumped a woman’s right to privacy under the 14th Amendment.

Seeing the debate this way makes the pro- and anti- argument one of degree rather than fundamental difference. To a conservative Catholic, the human rights of an embryo become operative at the moment of conception; to liberal justice Harry Blackmun, author of Roe v Wade, they are operative at the point of viability; to some, they are operative at a baby’s first breath. But in all cases, there is the question of human rights, the appropriateness of their application, and their relationship to the rights of the mother—to privacy, to life (when continuing a pregnancy is life-threatening), to having a say over when and with whom to have a baby.

The rights question, while putting the debate on equal terms, underscores why there can never be universal consensus on abortion from a moral, ethical, religious or legal standpoint in the same way there has always been for, say, infanticide. This is why there should never be a constitutional amendment banning abortion, as it would enshrine in the Constitution the beliefs of some religious factions to the exclusion of others, which is itself inherently unconstitutional.

Thursday, October 12, 2017

Why Do We Need Assault Weapons, Again?

There’s a lot of debate about whether the 2nd Amendment guarantees the right to own AR-15s and other assault weapons; a federal appeals court upheld Maryland’s ban, but this is not settled law.

A separate question is why people need assault weapons in the first place. The answer given by gun rights advocates is that they are necessary to defend against tyranny.

There are a few things to say about this.

This is not supported by the 2nd Amendment. 


While an individual right to gun ownership has been affirmed by the Heller decision, there is nothing in the Constitution to justify the “defense against tyranny” argument. The purpose of militias as set out in Article 1, section 8 is “to execute the laws of the Union, suppress insurrections, and repel invasions."

So the 2nd Amendment, created to ensure the maintenance of a well-regulated militia, was designed with suppressing insurrections in mind, not fermenting them.

Not that citizens have ever had much luck taking arms against their own government, no matter the number of weapons involved. I have more to say about this in a 2014 post comparing the importance of the 1st and 2nd amendments.

Many gun owners would not recognize tyranny if it bit them in the ass. 


We have a president who calls the press “the enemy of the people,” goes out of his way to condemn peaceful protest (Kapernick et all) and equivocates in the face of Nazis and Klansmen, yet none of his supporters seem to recognize this as a slippery slope to any kind of tyranny. The reason for this is that tyrannical, illiberal regimes do not rise up by sending jackbooted thugs to VFW meetings and county fairs; they use patriotism, populism and demagoguery to exploit cultural capital and set groups against each other, making core supporters feel protected and free.

Most Germans in the Nazi era did not feel tyrannized; they stood by as others bore the brunt of oppression. Meanwhile the basic protections of civil society and a free press were pulled out from under them. Oh, and they had guns (Nazi gun laws deregulated the acquisition and transfer of rifles and shotguns). They had them, but had no desire to use them, because the Nazi party was widely popular.

What are you gonna do, really? 


Let's say your worst fears come true. Red Dawn paratroopers. Blue-helmeted UN invaders. The Khmer Rouge (of course, the Khmer Rouge went after liberals, intellectuals, artists and urbanites, which ought to make you wonder why despots find these type of people—not NRA types—so threatening). In your apocalyptic scenario, did we lose the military, or are they on the side of the patriots? If the regime has military support, you’re toast. If not, then what's your Bushmaster for? Do the tyrants have air power? Can they simply obliterate you, the way Germany obliterated Warsaw? What’s your game plan, man?? Hide in the bunker until smoked out, or blown up? Is this how you preserve freedom?

Here's a better idea. Fight for transparency, equal protections, science-based policy, good government and constitutional rights (beyond weaponry), and against corruption, oligarchy, money in politics, vote suppression and illiberalism. Time and energy much better spent, and no chance of accidentally shooting yourself in the foot.

Thursday, September 21, 2017

Decrying Religious Tests While Pushing Doctrine

I disagree with senator Feinstein and other Democrats for questioning judicial nominee Amy Barrett about her Catholic faith, which does constitute a kind of religious test for public office. Judges should not be subject to grilling about their religious convictions (or lack thereof) as an indication of how they will interpret and uphold the law.

I have to say though, it would help matters if conservative bishops would not threaten to deny communion to Catholic lawmakers seeking in good faith to do their jobs. It’s hypocritical to decry religious tests on the one hand and then, on the other, hold believers’ souls for ransom if they refuse to toe a particular doctrinal line.

Tuesday, August 29, 2017

How the Right Embraces Climate Change

If you believe the science, and even the least sensationalistic predictions of what global warming will do in the 21st century, then you also believe that people on all points of the political spectrum will eventually come to accept the reality of human-caused climate change.

The questions is, how do conservatives get there? After years of denial, hostility and obstruction, how will those on the right manage to fold this particular piece of reality into their worldview?

I think a clue to this process can be seen in the evolution of the right’s thinking about the Iraq War. Back in the 2000s, of course, opposition to our invasion, occupation and mismanagement of Iraq was central to the politics of the left and a core point of division between red and blue. Those who opposed the war were, to many Bush supporters, unpatriotic, terrorist-loving traitors. To Democrats, the war was an immoral, unnecessary war of choice spilling horrific amounts of blood and treasure, while doing nothing to prevent the spread of terrorism. These contrasting narratives largely defined the 2004 (Bush-Kerry) presidential election.

Today, in 2017, we have a conservative, populist president who campaigned on retroactive opposition to the Iraq War (even claiming—falsely—he was against it from the beginning), voted into office by legions of former Bush supporters who now seem to feel about Iraq largely the way Kerry supporters did 13 years ago. How does this happen?

Selective memory and a re-ordering of the significance of events to support a revised narrative. Today, the populist right has embraced the idea that Iraq was part of a globalist political philosophy that runs through mainstream Republican and Democratic thinking. Iraq, they believe, stains Democrats as much as Republicans.

The primary evidence is the bipartisan “yes” vote in Congress in October 2002 authorizing military action against Saddam Hussein. Forgotten is the mountain of false and distorted intelligence put out by the Bush administration at the time to convince Congress that Hussein harbored weapons of mass destruction; the subsequent opposition to the war by mainstream Democratic politicians; the extreme unlikelihood that the war ever would have happened with a Democrat in the White House in 2003; and—most importantly—the strong grassroots opposition to the war among leftists and moderates which began in the run-up to the invasion and only strengthened as the war progressed, and the failure of the grassroots right to pull their support, even after no WMDs were found and Bush’s “mission accomplished” turned into a quagmire.

So how does this work for climate change? Via the Future Right’s downplaying of Al Gore and left-wing environmental activism, Obama’s support of climate accords and those on the left (and moderate right) supporting policies like a carbon tax, and instead putting the focus on the forces of globalization and the political elite’s failure to act for reasons of economic self-interest. “Look at all the money given to Democrat [sic] politicians back in the twenty-teens by [insert carbon-emitting multinational],” they’ll say. It will be a much harder sell, given the very clear history of the right standing in the way of progress on climate, but I think they will try to pull it off.

Some might say it doesn’t matter how conservatives get there, as long as they get there. Let them have their own version of history, if that helps. But the problem, as with Iraq, is how much damage is done before they make that leap—and in this case, much of it may be irreversible.

How can the Current Left help them along? By doing what they can to de-politicize the climate debate. The fate of our planet (and species) should not be a political shibboleth, and if the right will cling fiercely (for now) to climate change denial as a cultural and philosophical touchstone, the left must try to loosen that grip by not using environmentalism as a political bludgeon.

Friday, August 18, 2017

The ACLU and Holding the Line on Speech Protections

In the wake of the violence in Charlottesville this week, some are calling on the ACLU to rethink its historic commitment to defending free speech across the political spectrum, regardless of the unpopularity or offensiveness of the message. The best way to ensure an equal voice for disenfranchised groups, it is argued, is for the ACLU to consider power dynamics and historical context when choosing whose First Amendment rights to defend.

I have a hard time with this position. It’s untenable to ask the ACLU to choose which political speech is worth protecting under the law and which isn’t. Free speech is not like housing or education or health care, where law and policy can be doctored to level the playing field; it’s the fundamental bedrock of democracy and civil society.

Even the perception that legal means are being used to amplify some people’s speech and suppress others’ (whether aimed right or left) is politically destabilizing and promotes radicalization. The alt-right, while not members of a historically disenfranchised group, already see themselves as marginalized victims of a liberal establishment. It’s important for the ACLU to maintain its historic stance as nonpartisan defender of civil rights.

Then there is the generalized erosion of public space, leaving us with fewer and fewer neutral forums for demonstration and debate. With private entities such as Twitter and Google blocking content as they please, now is not the time to weaken or bifurcate speech rights.

We should instead focus on, and support, all the ACLU does to promote freedom of expression, voting rights, criminal justice reform, religious freedom and the separation of church and state.

Tuesday, July 18, 2017

Suburbs From KOP to Voorhees Embrace New ‘Main Streets’ —But Not Cherry Hill

Michaelle Bond’s article in the Inquirer about citified “main streets” coming to the suburbs has everything you’d expect: interviews with developers and city planners, somewhat silly-sounding quotes from random members of the public, and the hint of snark (all that astroturf!) usually found in the Inky's coverage of anything suburban.

Really, though, what’s happening in King of Prussia, Exton and elsewhere is better than what came before (in the recent past) and better than any contemporary alternatives if one accepts the inevitability of growth. The article’s observation that these complexes “cost open space” overlooks the notion that these high-density projects gobble far less land than traditional housing tracts and shopping centers.

It also reminds me, yet again, of how tremendously stupid Cherry Hill was to reject a similar (and at the time, ahead of the curve) proposal to redevelop the Garden State Park property on Rt. 70 along pedestrian and transit-friendly lines. Not only was the tract perfectly situated to give the sprawly township the semblance of a town center, it lies adjacent to a (woefully underused) passenger train station, on NJ Transit’s Atlantic City Line.

I was working for a newspaper in Haddonfield at the time development of the land was being debated (2005-06) and remember then-mayor Bernie Platt trumpeting the approved plan as “mixed-use,” a politician-speak mangling of that term if there ever was one. True mixed-use developments are dense and pedestrian friendly; the only thing “mixed use” about today’s Garden State Park is that one can drive to the grocery store, drive to the restaurant, or drive to the townhouse—or risk life and limb dodging SUVs while walking across a sea of asphalt.

Garden State Park: A sea of sprawl... and a train station.


Wednesday, June 14, 2017

Appropriation is Not Necessarily Exploitation

I wrote this in response to a friend's Facebook call for comments on a New York Times piece, "In Defense of Cultural Appropriation."

I think much of 20th century social progress was abetted, if not in some cases directly driven, by what many today dismissively call “cultural appropriation.”

This more or less began in the '20s with nascent integration in jazz, and really picked up steam after the war, as the nation gradually grew to understand African-American culture as more than just inferior or quaint.

Remember, as recently as the turn of the last century, W.E.B. Du Bois had to plead for cultural relevance and respect on the basis of “the American fairy tales and folklore [being] Indian and African.” How far we have come since then, with mainstreaming and universal acceptance of art forms rooted in black culture as quintessentially American.

Especially, and somewhat ironically, in the South—a cultural cauldron in ways going far beyond the violence and victories of Civil Rights. What we call R&B, Rock & Roll—even folk, country and gospel music—was the result of many decades (centuries, really) of cultural cross-pollination, often driven, now as ever, by talented young people more interested in inspiration than labels and boundaries.

It’s true Elvis was seen as a white guy who could sound black, and had his first hit with an Arthur Crudup blues song. It’s also true that Chuck Berry was considered a black guy who could sound white, and had his first hit with a reworking of a western swing fiddle tune first recorded by Bob Wills.

Throw into the mix influences criss-crossing the pond—most importantly the effect of American music on young Britons in the 50s and 60s, which subsequently awakened young white America to this nation’s full musical heritage—and the positive effect this had on the fortunes of a generation of black musicians—and the picture becomes even more complicated. (At the risk of sounding unfashionably uncynical, it's been a long time since pop music appropriation equaled exploitation, despite what Jesse Williams may believe.)

Art does not fit into the neat boundaries proposed by academicians, and never will.

Tuesday, May 16, 2017

The Arguments Against Abortion Are Truly Out of This World

Of all the arguments against abortion, the one I find most ridiculous is the “if my mom had an abortion, I wouldn’t be here” reasoning.

So what? If my mom had a headache the night I was conceived, I wouldn’t be here either.

My mom had a miscarriage in 1968. If she had carried the baby to term and had given birth in ’69, it’s certain I would not be here, because my parents would not have wanted another child so soon. So I owe my life to the early termination of a pregnancy.

But again, why does any of that matter? A million things could have happened to prevent my existing. It's futile to dwell on the what-haves, near-misses and might-have-beens. Once I emerged into the world, I became a person—not in some Platonic, image-of-God way, but by my importance to family, community and society. By joining the whirl (and whorl) of existence.

I also find offensive the idea that parents of special-needs children have some special right to comment on the morality of abortion. The dynamic is the same whether the child is born healthy or sick, conventionally formed or not; once in the world, the infant joins the community of man. There is no cosmic symbolism to the birth of a special-needs child; this child is loved for who they are, like any other child.

Worst of all is the notion that mothers who sacrifice their lives on behalf of an unborn child are nobler, more saintly, than the rest. There is a Catholic saint, Gianna Beretta Molla, who was canonized for her refusal to save her life by having surgery that would, as an unintended consequence, end the life of her first-term fetus. She eventually died after giving birth, leaving behind a husband and four children.

Here we have a sacrifice on behalf of an idea—that of the inviolability of a zygote implanted on the placenta—taking precedence over the prerogatives of the born. Her choice was truly not “of this world” because it put a theory of personhood above the actuality of personhood, and turned the suffering of the body into a signifier of a higher cause (what could be more Catholic than that!). The mother-to-be becomes mortal vessel for the divine spark. Perhaps this is best understood as the dehumanization of a woman as tradeoff for the humanization of the embryo.

Believing that people are formed in the word and by the world means believing that the world matters; it is not just a symbol or staging ground for some higher or future purpose. Each one of us is here because of a series of dynamics, adaptations and choices stretching back millions of years; not random, but beautiful. This includes the choice of whether and how our parents decided to get pregnant and have a baby.

Tuesday, May 2, 2017

Campus Free Speech and Snowflakes

In his much-discussed Times piece, “What Snowflakes Get Right About Free Speech,” Ulrich Baer cites the philosopher Jean-François Lyotard to bolster his claim that some speech should be banned on college campuses because it has a chilling effect on marginalized groups.

“Lyotard," he writes, "shifted attention away from the content of free speech to the way certain topics restrict speech as a public good."

Essentially this is an argument about legitimization. Giving Holocaust deniers an equal voice with Holocaust survivors elevates their position while diminishing those of the people bearing witness to personal and collective suffering.

I understand this argument but do not believe it follows that censoring viewpoints from a university campus is necessary to “ensure the conditions of free speech for a greater group of people.”

Baer’s argument that students curious abut the views of Richard Spencer or Ann Coulter can simply can go to the Internet undermines the central logic of campus free speech—that airing ideas in a university setting brings perspective (and tools for refutation) that are not available to someone browsing Reddit.

I would argue that the high profile of figures like Spencer is a result of, rather than threat to, the gains of traditionally disenfranchised groups in recent decades. Unfortunately for bigots, the genie is out of the battle; no amount of rhetoric will prevent members of Hillel at Auburn from participating in debate as fully recognized members of the community.

Maybe We're All 'Snowflakes' Now...


Baer thinks giving the Ann Coulters of the world a platform necessarily forces some groups “to defend their human worth.” But Coulter herself, who like many on the Right suffer from a victimhood complex making them feel as if they are the ones being denied (ethnic or cultural) rights, speaks in these same terms.

So perhaps the paradigm shift effected by identity politics has changed the terms of discourse—even for racists—from notions of inherent superiority to those of ethnic nationalism and cultural integrity. This too is odious, but the politics-based debates of today do not foreclose the possibility of disenfranchised groups maintaining a voice in the same way that pseudo-scientific, mytho-folkloric and religion-based arguments of the past did.

Monday, April 17, 2017

From the Right: A Vision of 'Communitarian Conservatism'


Interesting things are happening on the Right, such as a movement to take what’s seen as the positive elements of Trumpism to formulate a new conservatism opposed to both the neoliberal consensus founded by Ronald Reagan and free-market fundamentalism.

Julius Krein, thirty-something founder and editor of American Affairs, promotes a kind of economic nationalism he calls communitarian conservatism. It’s built around the idea of “grounding the economy in society”—as in, the structures and relationships of a stable, functioning community (he's vague on this point, maybe by design)—rather than the ideology of think-tank intellectuals.

This includes more government intervention in some situations. Regulation is not always bad, he says, if balanced by strong democratic institutions and accountability. He’s highly critical of free trade. 

Paraphrasing Krein: the Right reflexively celebrates capitalism without thinking of how modern capitalism is different from Adam Smith or the founding fathers, or how “corporate cartels” are harmful to classical free-market principals. 

Krein even hints that socialized healthcare may be an inevitability: “The idea that the only health care is free market health care is basically impossible and doesn’t make any sense.”

But he’s no Bernie Sanders in a suit. The racism and xenophobia of Trumpism clearly does not bother him. He is generally dismissive of such concerns or even sympathetic where he sees the result as helping to define society and strengthen its boundaries.

This is where you start to get the unsettling feeling that this vision, an intellectual projection of values at the core of Jacksonian communalism, could slide into something like National Socialism.

Klein outlines his views in a podcast from Princeton University's Woodrow Wilson School. It's worth a listen for anyone interested in trends across the political spectrum.

http://wws.princeton.edu/news-and-events/news/item/politics-polls-35-future-conservatism-trump-era

Friday, April 7, 2017

Enough With the 'False Flag' Bullshit

I really hate the throwing around of the term “false flag.” I’ve heard it applied to the Boston bombing, Newtown—a lot—and now, the Syria gas attacks.

In addition to being ignorant and cynical in a teenager-at-the-breakfast-table sort of way, it is an egregious insult to the soldiers and first responders who deal with foreign and domestic horrors on the ground, journalists who risk their lives reporting violence, and of course the grieving loved ones of innocent victims of terrorism and mass shootings.

Does the Alex Jones crowd really believe their vast conspiracies involve inconsolable parents, sheriffs and police officers, GIs and guardsmen, journalists, community witnesses, local and federal investigators, lawyers, psychologists, social workers, etc, etc—with not one whistleblower among the vast legions of deep state lackeys ever spilling the “truth” about what really happened?

Do these keyword-banging paranoiacs, safe in their suburban homes, understand what it is to have their families, neighborhoods or towns rocked by violence of the sort perpetrated in Syria and Newtown?

It’s easy, when you’re comfortable and safe, to flippantly dismiss the sufferings and labors of those who do the hard work of propping up civilization.

But who cares, amirite? You’ve got some guns locked away in that cabinet over there. 

Seriously though, enough with the false flag bullshit.

Thursday, April 6, 2017

Is Viktor Orbán a Bellwether for the U.S.?

Hungary's Viktor Orbán is providing the world with a particularly stark example of how a populist leader with authoritarian tendencies can lead a modern bureaucratic state away from openness, free discourse and the checks and balances of civil society. 

Orbán, who praises “ethnic homogeneity,” is seeking to shut down Budapest’s highly regarded Central European University.

This really is one of those “which side are you on?” signifiers. Do you support liberal democracy or the illiberal state? In the name of security and identity, should America become more like Russia and Turkey? (They are democracies, after all!)

This is where all the Nazi talk in recent years from both the Left and the Right is revealed as stupid and distracting. If you believe in plurality, openness and accountability, a free press, research independence and government checks on oligarchy… then a slide toward Viktor Orbán’s Hungary is what you should fear.

Tuesday, April 4, 2017

MOVE Bombing: Cops Forced to Act Like Soldiers

It’s been announced that the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission has approved a marker for the site of the 1985 MOVE bombing in West Philadelphia. A statement from the Jubilee School, sponsor of the monument, states the dropping of explosives on a rooftop bunker during an armed standoff “paved the way for government assistance to, and tolerance of, police brutality.”

There should be a historical marker about MOVE. I’m troubled though by the framing of those terrible events as an extreme instance of police brutality. It’s better to talk about MOVE alongside groups like the Branch Davidians or Symbionese Liberation Army—radical movements occupying heavily-armed compounds that became sites of showdowns with law enforcement.

In all these cases police were put in the position of having to conduct essentially a military operation against people hunkered down with an arsenal of weapons. MOVE had already shot and killed a Philadelphia police officer in an earlier standoff. The decisions made by the police were terrible but the options before them were also terrible.

These things always seem to end in fire. In Waco, better trained and equipped ATF agents could not stop the carnage. The difference with MOVE was it occurred in the middle of a densely-populated city neighborhood.

If we’re going to allow private citizens to hoard weapons then police need training in urban warfare. It’s the unintended consequence of Second Amendment fundamentalism.